Popular People

KidNetworkI don’t particularly enjoy church, so I don’t go, but my wife does and she takes the kids every Sunday. My daughter has been volunteering to help babysit the toddlers during the first service, and on those weeks, I take her there and drop her off. When I arrive too early (she doesn’t like to go in until she has to) I end up driving around the parking lot with her until the exact time. We chat. The other morning, while driving around the parking lot to waste time, my daughter spotted some little girl coming in and said, “Ugh, it’s Cindy. I don’t like her. You can tell she’s going to be one of the popular girls.”

I thought about that for a second and then asked, “what defines a popular girl?” Because I wanted to know what she thought it meant, although I suspected I already knew. “Do you mean someone who is going to be pretty, but makes fun of other people, mocks them, and generally makes anyone she doesn’t like miserable?”

To this, she replied in the affirmative. To her, that’s what a popular girl is, and she seemed surprised I didn’t know this (not that I didn’t, I was just verifying her perceptions on this issue). That’s pretty much my opinion on popularity as well, and her answer made me consider what makes popular people popular. It’s an interesting topic.

In children, popularity is different than it is for adults. It’s more concrete and discernible for children. As adults, I think most of us seldom think of or consider “popularity” anymore. We have a circle of friends – or “acquaintances” – or co-workers – or just people we know. And if we think about popularity at all, it’s more about our popularity in a specific group and more along the lines of how others perceive or value us. In other words, individual relationships between specific people. We’re still social animals, but the pool we swim in is smaller in that regard simply because our exposure to other people is far more limited. Our exposure is limited to our environment, and our environment is determined by our lives. We find like minded people because they do the same things we do, enjoy the same entertainment. But for children, who exist in a school environment, that’s not entirely established yet. They swim in an enormous pool with shifting tides.

Those children who are nice to others aren’t necessarily popular in school environments. It might happen that they are, but more frequently, it is those children who possess the power to run others down that become popular. It’s a negative rather than a positive that enforces popularity. They become popular out of fear. Being friends with them is a defense for the less popular. For the less popular, being friends with a popular child is an investment in the hope that this will then prevent or dissuade the popular child from seeking to destroy them via character assassination. They hope to avoid being run down, and mocked either overtly or covertly. Popularity maintenance isn’t a positive thing in youth, it’s a negative thing. Being popular frequently means that an individual is feared by those who are less popular. The popular children have influence and power among their peers, and it’s a use it or lose it situation. If they don’t occasionally rip someone apart, they risk slowly losing power.

You might think this is limited to girls, but it isn’t. Boys have the same type of pecking order, its simply less covert and more up-front. The boys are more likely to call each other names to their faces and less likely to discuss someone when they aren’t present. They desire an immediate reaction, a sadistic form of feedback. The girls are more likely to run someone down when they’re not around. They want the reaction of their peers more than the target. They want to manipulate the opinions of others and witness the reaction to that effect as it ripples through the rumor mill. It works both ways, of course, but this is the statistically more likely behavior between genders. It all boils down to non-physical bullying though.

What would it be like, I wonder, if the popular kids were those kids who never talked badly about someone? What if the kids who were popular were the “nice” kids who defended others when they were put down, who tried to increase the self-esteem of others rather than destroy it? What if, instead of a negative feedback enforcement, popularity became a positive feedback enforcement? How could we ever make it thus? Our influence of youth is tenuous and unpredictable. They pay far more attention to their peers and to media than they do to their parents. And if you attempt to isolate them from that, you’re only crippling them, or so I believe. I know many who encapsulate their children, seeking to isolate them from media in an attempt to influence them, mitigate their exposure to experiences that they determine are negative. That’s a personal parenting decision, and I don’t judge them for doing it, but it isn’t my way. I don’t let them watch just anything, mind you, I do draw the line. But if a pop song contains a few expletives, or a movie makes a drug reference, or a video game involves shooting bloody zombies, I’m not going to censor it. I want my adult kids to be able to see others from the inside and accept them from the outside. That means living in both worlds – the real and the illusionary. They get to decide where they want to walk.

When I look at the school system today, I think the units – the classes – the groups – should be smaller and more focused. Interests should be identified earlier and promoted. Groups should be analyzed and created for like-minded interests. Of course, all of this takes money and time and work. How do you remove popularity as a negative from the equation? Online schools can make that possible, and we’ve begun experimenting with that, but people learn in different ways. Some are tactile learners. Some are visual learners. Some are auditory learners. Some need the structure of social interaction and some do not. Some have no motivation and won’t do anything they don’t consider fun unless they’re forced to engage in it. Others are quit interested in learning, and will do so on their own without prompting. Most fall somewhere in-between depending on subject. Future high schools will likely be composed of a mixture of physical classrooms and online classrooms. Teachers will have both online and offline students. Social pressures will be managed in this regard – allowing students to withdraw from them at will. If a student is having a problem in a class socially, they can detach to an online version of the class. That may be in the school’s study hall or computer lab or library. You can imagine giving them cubicles to use, places where they can simply take the class by themselves if they have another offline class coming up and can’t leave the school. It could even be that a “classroom” won’t exist anymore. Students will be given a cubical, and take all their classes from that one location.

What will popularity mean in the schools of the future? Maybe, someday, it will become a good thing? Maybe, someday, it will be the good students.

15 Responses

  1. I went to a church for many years that ended up splitting over two cliques that boiled down to two ‘power’ players in a ‘popularity’ battle. It is sad to see 50-something year old men behave in this manner. A church deacon using his power and influence to get enough people on his side to force a coup and force the pastor into retirement. A new pastor is hired and after a year this produced an even deeper split as the new pastor became more and more questionable. Watching this type of juvenile behavior among men with nearly grown children of there own is part of the reason I moved away from being a church go-er.

    • Church hierarchies are political machines, yes. I’ve perused a few of them, and noted the friction points between the individual members. In many ways, they’re not much different than a city council. They can be overtly professional, and covertly immature. Sometimes that immaturity leaks out, and when it comes from the leaders, you have to step back and remember that despite what they may profess to believe, whatever moral high ground they claim is still a factor of personal perception and personal ego. They are, after all, human, and churches are human constructs.

      • Which is why I don’t go to them anymore. I’ve been reading comparative religion since childhood and the overwhelming, common element, is that churches and religions (rules and expressions of religion) are all human constructs and intrinsically tied to the cultural settings in which they developed. The spiritual ideals behind the shape and form of the religion are surprisingly basic and not at all dissimilar, one from another.

  2. >>What would it be like, I wonder, if the popular kids were those kids who never talked badly about someone?<<

    When you are popular for being nice, it makes people search harder for the thing that must be wrong with you that you "need" to be punished for.

    It's still worth being nice. I suppose it builds character.

    • P.S. I clicked “post” too quickly: I’m impressed with your insight into the world of girls. It’s a complicated place. Your daughter is lucky!

    • Good point. Thanks. :)

  3. Sounds like growing up is still as hard as it’s always been. Wanting to fit in, wanting to be liked, sensitive to criticism, making friends, being betrayed, dealing with bullies, etc. Finding your way is tough when you don’t yet know where you want to go.

    • Right, or who you want to be. There’s always that conflict between the personality you’ve inherited and the one you envision for yourself. It takes all of us a lifetime to iron it out. It probably wouldn’t take so long if we’d quit changing it, but where’s the fun in that?

  4. Wasn’t popular in HS though had my share of friends in all groups. Funny at my reunion, the “popular” kids acted like we were the best of friends.

    • I haven’t gone to any of my reunions. Our valedictorian had a heart attack and died right after high school, and our salutatorian committed suicide. I’m not sure if any of the others are left. It was a really small class. At this point, our reunion could probably be held in an ATM vestibule.

  5. ‘It could even be that a “classroom” won’t exist anymore. Students will be given a cubical, and take all their classes from that one location.’

    I had that experience at IBM Guided Learning Center Manila in 1986. No human tutors.

    • ‘It could even be that a “classroom” won’t exist anymore. Students will be given a cubical, and take all their classes from that one location.’

      I had that experience at IBM Guided Learning Center Manila in 1986. No human tutors.

      • How did you like it?

      • I enjoyed it immensely! I learn better and very fast that way.

  6. You think too much … but that’s a good thing.

    When I was an elementary school kid, the principal introduced me to new students who were around my age … and had me show them around.
    … at Jr. High School … the same thing … even though I was kind of a new student as well.

    In hindsight (or speaking out of my ass) … I don’t think I was popular, cool, or in the “in” crowd, but I was sociable, knew everyone, and no one bothered me in a bad way.

    note: now that I think about it, teachers do know somethings.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

There is always one more story to be told...

Writing ate my soul - and I'm perfectly happy with that.


When will we ever learn?: Common sense and nonsense about today's public schools in America.

She's a Maineiac

just another plaid-wearin' java-sippin' girl

Fire and Air

Babblings of interest -- to me, that is

Parenting And Stuff

Not a "how to be a great parent" blog


clawing at the keys

P. Emerson Williams

Necrofuturist Art


explorations of mindful fatherhood

The Consortium of the Curious

For those bemused by the bizarre and engrossed in the esoteric.

reluctant writer girl

There is nothing to writing, all you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed. - Ernest Hemingway

Beneath the Tin Foil Hat

Speak The Truth, Even If Your Voice Shakes.

"You Jivin' Me, Turkey?"

***"Maybe this World is Another Planet's HELL." - Aldous Huxley***

Is everyone stupid?

Some of my observations and opinions on current events

Literature and Libation

Through it all, your spirit's alive

The abrasive embrace

Thoughts about Thoughtlessness

The Jiggly Bits

...because life is funny.

Stay Abnormal

Random thoughts and rants from an Abnormal


Rants My Way


Hikari's Food/Japanophile and Other Interesting Stuff blog

An explosion of creative madness

Please take a look at my novel in progress Humanity: The fall and be critical. Thankyou!

Curmudgeon at Large

Short bursts of curmudgeonry on any topic.

Wretched Richard's Almanac

Five minutes here and the rest of your day will seem much more important


A great WordPress.com site

livin' like a freebird

cynical realism for the common man

hippie cahier


Bill Boyd - The Literacy Adviser

Learning and Teaching Literacy in the Digital Age

The Quick Brown Fox

My thoughts laid out from A to Z.

Urbannight's Blog

Looking at the world at 40.


For when you wanna go "WTF did I just read?"


laughingstock of the Internet.

Typical Tracy

Memories & Musings of an Average, Middle Aged, Mother of Two

Stuff Kids Write

Like stuff adults write. But funnier.

The Shut-in Stand-Up

A comedic look at modern life from the perspective of a traumatized but standing up shut-in.


This WordPress.com site is the cat’s pajamas

Mystery of Iniquity

"...doth already work."

Bill McCurry

Fantasy Fiction That Bleeds Laughter

Miss Demure Restraint

Lost I may yet reach my goal . . . Without finding all that I seek . . . I might still be made whole.

Sanctity Rapture

Wait....am I still here? Jesus where are you?

Sky Diaries

Lynn Biederstadt's space about writing. About the journey that writers take. Despite themselves.

Trippin' in Thailand

Another Beautiful Adventure

Randomize ME

Freebies, Deals, Reviews, Music, Books & other random things I like!

The Good Greatsby

The humor blog of Paul Johnson: He doesn't do it for the money. But he wouldn't object if you gave him some.

Gruffguano's Weblog

Just another WordPress.com weblog


The Official Blog of JERK Magazine at Syracuse University

Politics or Poppycock

A Look From the Left At Politics, Politicians, Policies and Issues of National Concern


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 470 other followers

%d bloggers like this: