Post-Election Re-Publicanization

So, after defeat by a president with a questionable second half of his term, in a weak economy, under circumstances that would have defeated most other presidents, Republicans are understandably pissed. How will the Republican Party seek to redefine themselves this time? Have they figured out what ruined their chances? Do they think it was their candidate, or their message? They have a lot of theories, some as insane as thinking that Romney was not conservative enough. Some as logical as looking at the demographic shift. Others blaming the fickle hand of mother nature. And a few looking at the issues themselves and the cities where Democrats won.

Let me offer a hypothesis:

A lot of people did not vote for Obama – they voted against Conservative ideology.

There were a lot of things about Romney that voters didn’t like. Flip-flopping on major issues was one of them, but not the largest factors by a long shot. Immigration reform and his previous statements regarding immigration were factors for many people. His anti-abortion stance, while moderated, was not in line with the majority of Americans, and certain members of his party made idiotic statements regarding their views on abortion rights that alienated many women. Conservatives, as a whole, lost on a lot of points in this round. Romney won among Christian evangelicals, seniors, and under-educated white men. 57 percent of the white vote went to Romney. In the new demographic of America, that simply is not enough.

Some of us saw the opposition to Obamacare and remembered the Bush years. For eight years, the Bush administration had the opportunity to engage in health care reform and did little to nothing. Before that, Hillary Clinton tried to push health care reform and was unsuccessful during the eight years of the Clinton administration. Something still needed to be done. Republicans have blocked health care reform at nearly every opportunity. So when Obama came into office, he took up all the previously proposed Republican ideas regarding health care reform, packaged them, and crammed them through congress while he still had a Democratic majority. He knew this was his only chance to do it. And it wasn’t perfect. It was a compromise between a socialist and a capitalist health care system. It is not Canada’s health care in any way. But the Republicans were very angry because he didn’t give them any choice, and even though a lot of the ideas were theirs, they did everything they could to lampoon health care legislation, doing such a good job that even people who had no idea as to what the legislation entailed were given to hate it.

The Republicans could have embraced Obamacare, and stated that rather than repealing it, their intent was to change the legislation, streamline it, make it better. Instead they stated their clear intention to rip it out, and then selected the very candidate who had already instrumented the same ideas as Obamacare in his own state. The hypocrisy of this was evident to many.

And hypocrisy was a big part of the problem.

Romney continually criticized Obama’s economic ideas while giving little ammunition for Obama. It was a wonderful tactic, that would have worked in earlier years. He did this by creating vague concepts about what his own economic reforms would entail. He talked of closing tax loopholes without identifying which loopholes would be closed. He used the “apology tour” rhetoric, which was ridiculous as no such apologies were ever made. He refused to release more than two years of his own tax returns, while insisting his own vice presidential candidates release many more years of their own tax returns. And he claimed he was better at being bipartisan than Obama, when Obama could not work in a bipartisan manner because he was negotiating with a congress under Republicans that openly stated that their first priority was to ensure he was not re-elected. They never intended to work with him, only against him. And they’re STILL in power.

Despite Romney’s shortcomings, I think he was the right candidate for the Republicans. He was their best chance to win the election from among the candidates that ran for their party’s nomination. He was the most moderate of the extremists, the most appealing, and the least radical. The problem was not Romney as much as the platform he was given to run with. A platform that largely involved negative freedoms. Taking away a woman’s right to choose is a removal of freedom. Preventing gays from marrying is the prevention of freedom. Taking away a person’s right to healthcare is a removal of freedom. Restricting a person’s ability to become a US citizen is the prevention of freedom.

Americans don’t want restrictions, they want freedom. They want the government to either help them or get out of their way. They’re willing to pay for that help if they get what they’re paying for. Americans are willing to invest in government if they get a good return. That doesn’t mean government needs to be bigger, it just needs to be better.

Will Republicans learn this lesson and move away from restrictions? Will they figure out that what they really need to do is focus on intelligent leadership, proven methods for reducing the debt, techniques for streamlining and cutting inefficient programs? I’m certain Obama will be interested in Boehner’s ideas about cutting loopholes in the tax code to raise revenue. I’m also certain Boehner will resist any attempt to raise taxes on the wealthy. Who will act bipartisan?

When it comes to enacting new legislation that actually helps people, I fully expect the Democrats to take the lead. Republicans won’t. They are the party of no. But I expect Democrats to be sloppy when they’re working alone. When it comes to cleaning up that slop, I expect Republicans to identify the pork and cut it out. They MUST work together. But right now, the Republicans hold their ground, stick to outmoded ideals, and allow religious agendas to rule them with archaic concepts and cultural relics.

Some have said it is time for a third party. Others have said it is time for the elimination of political parties altogether. Personally, I’m in favor of either, but I don’t see either happening. In the past, it was possible, (or at least more possible), to cross the aisle and make a deal. It was possible for Republicans and Democrats to meet in the middle. This is the time we need to return to. But we can’t, because both sides are sticking to hardline concepts – the Republicans only slightly more than the Democrats.

Return to the center, Republicans. The country needs you. Look to Reagan if you have to. Did Reagan raise taxes? If you don’t know the answer to that, then look at his record.

3 Responses

  1. You summed it up beautifully. Now we’ll have to see if Washington has learned anything from all this. Will the politicians finally start working together for the good of the country, or will they continue with their partisan poison and scorched earth policies and fiddle while the nation burns?

    Frankly, I’m no more optimistic about this than I was about the election itself. Maybe it’s just a defense mechanism, trying to keep my expectations low to avoid disappointment later.

  2. Throughout our history as a nation, there have always been more than two parties. But two parties have always risen to the top while shoving most of the others out of the way. Over the years, these two parties have not been the ‘same’ two parties. Parties rise and parties fall. The Republican party has proven that it cannot move with the times and it clings to an era that no longer exist. Unless they can change to a fairly radical extent, they are on the downward slope. Their slide will eventually make room for a new or existing party to move forward and fill the gap.

  3. Just as ,monopolies are bad in the business world , so too is having only 2 political parties. You must have other parties in order to “to keep the bastards honest”. People are sick and tired of having such little choice in who leads the government. Especially when these parties are extremists at different ends of the spectrum.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

There is always one more story to be told...

Writing ate my soul - and I'm perfectly happy with that.


When will we ever learn?: Common sense and nonsense about today's public schools in America.

She's a Maineiac

just another plaid-wearin' java-sippin' girl

Fire and Air

Babblings of interest -- to me, that is

Parenting And Stuff

Not a "how to be a great parent" blog


clawing at the keys

P. Emerson Williams

Necrofuturist Art


explorations of mindful fatherhood

The Consortium of the Curious

For those bemused by the bizarre and engrossed in the esoteric.

reluctant writer girl

There is nothing to writing, all you do is sit down at a typewriter and bleed. - Ernest Hemingway

Beneath the Tin Foil Hat

Speak The Truth, Even If Your Voice Shakes.

"You Jivin' Me, Turkey?"

***"Maybe this World is Another Planet's HELL." - Aldous Huxley***

Is everyone stupid?

Some of my observations and opinions on current events

Literature and Libation

Through it all, your spirit's alive

The abrasive embrace

Thoughts about Thoughtlessness

The Jiggly Bits

...because life is funny.

Stay Abnormal

Random thoughts and rants from an Abnormal


Rants My Way


Hikari's Food/Japanophile and Other Interesting Stuff blog

An explosion of creative madness

Please take a look at my novel in progress Humanity: The fall and be critical. Thankyou!

Curmudgeon at Large

Short bursts of curmudgeonry on any topic.

Wretched Richard's Almanac

Five minutes here and the rest of your day will seem much more important


A great site

livin' like a freebird

cynical realism for the common man

hippie cahier!

Bill Boyd - The Literacy Adviser

Learning and Teaching Literacy in the Digital Age

The Quick Brown Fox

My thoughts laid out from A to Z.

Urbannight's Blog

Looking at the world at 40.


For when you wanna go "WTF did I just read?"

Typical Tracy

Memories & Musings of an Average, Middle Aged, Mother of Two

Stuff Kids Write

Like stuff adults write. But funnier.

The Shut-in Stand-Up

A comedic look at modern life from the perspective of a traumatized but standing up shut-in.


This site is the cat’s pajamas

Mystery of Iniquity

"...doth already work."

Bill McCurry

Fantasy Fiction That Bleeds Laughter

Miss Demure Restraint

Lost I may yet reach my goal . . . Without finding all that I seek . . . I might still be made whole.

Sanctity Rapture I still here? Jesus where are you?

Sky Diaries

Lynn Biederstadt's space about writing. About the journey that writers take. Despite themselves.

Trippin' in Thailand

Another Beautiful Adventure

Randomize ME

Freebies, Deals, Reviews, Music, Books & other random things I like!

The Good Greatsby

The humor blog of Paul Johnson: He doesn't do it for the money. But he wouldn't object if you gave him some.

Gruffguano's Weblog

Just another weblog


The Official Blog of JERK Magazine at Syracuse University

Politics or Poppycock

A Look From the Left At Politics, Politicians, Policies and Issues of National Concern


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 469 other followers

%d bloggers like this: